Part 2 (1/2)
”Because they never got my last payment. And I...I sent it. I sent it out over three weeks ago. They said they sent a notice, but I never got it. And, and...” She lowered her head and tears fell to her knees.
She had a stuffed animal collection, I was pretty sure. Her totaled Corolla had either a smiley face or a Jesus fish affixed to the b.u.mper. She read John Grisham novels, listened to soft rock, loved going to bridal showers, and had never seen a Spike Lee movie.
She had never expected anything like this to happen in her life.
”Karen,” I said softly, ”what's the name of your insurance company?”
She raised her head, wiped her tears with the back of her hand. ”State Mutual.”
”And the post office branch you sent the check through?”
”Well, I live in Newton Upper Falls,” she said, ”but I'm not sure. My boyfriend?” She looked down at her spotless white sneakers, as if abashed. ”He lives in Back Bay and I'm over there a lot.”
She said it as if it were a sin, and I found myself wondering where they grew people like her, and if there was a seed, and how I could get my hands on it if I ever had a daughter.
”Have you ever been late on a payment before?”
She shook her head. ”Never.”
”How long have you been insured there?”
”Since I graduated college. Seven years.”
”Where's Cody Falk live?”
She patted her eyes with the heels of her hands to make sure the tears were dry. She wore no makeup, so nothing had run. She was as blandly beautiful as any woman in a Noxzema ad.
”I don't know. But he's at the gym every night at seven.”
”What gym?”
”The Mount Auburn Club in Watertown.” She bit down on her lower lip, then tried for that Ivory Snow smile of hers. ”I feel so ridiculous.”
”Miss Nichols,” I said, ”you're not supposed to deal with people like Cody Falk. Do you understand that? No one is. He's just a bad person and you didn't do anything to cause this. He did.”
”Yeah?” She managed to get a full smile out, but fear and confusion still swam in her eyes.
”Yeah. He's the bad guy. He likes making people afraid.”
”He does.” She nodded. ”You see it in his eyes. The more uncomfortable he made me feel in the parking lot one night, the more he seemed to enjoy it.”
Bubba chuckled. ”You wanna talk uncomfortable? Just wait till we visit Cody.”
Karen Nichols looked at Bubba and for just a moment she seemed to pity Cody Falk.
In my office, I placed a call to my attorney, Cheswick Hartman.
Karen Nichols had driven off in her boyfriend's VW. I'd instructed her to drive straight to her insurance company and drop off a replacement check. When she said they wouldn't honor the claim, I a.s.sured her they would by the time she got there. She wondered aloud if she could pay my fee and I told her if she could afford one day, she'd be fine, because that's all this would take.