Part 23 (1/2)
Meseujac Confinement and banishment..........................O Chabanon Confinement and banishment..........................O Jos. Maille Absent with leave...................................a
69. LA CHARENTE (ANGOULEME)
Bellegarde Death...............................................+ Chedanau Death, with discussion as to time...................D Guinberteau Death...............................................+ Chazaud Death...............................................+ G Brun Death...............................................+ Ribereau Death...............................................+ I Cuvelier Death...............................................+ De Vars Confinement and banishment..........................O Maulde Confinement and banishment..........................O
70. CHARENTE INFERIEURE (SAINTES)
Bernard Death...............................................+ I Nion Death...............................................+
Page 211
Echa.s.seriaux Death...............................................+ Breard Death...............................................+ Ruamps Death...............................................+ I Lozeau Death, with discussion as to time...................D Vinet Death...............................................+ Garnicr Death...............................................+ Giraud ”As a legislator I think it most beneficial that ”Louis should live.”................................O D'Autriche ”I declare that my sentiments are subject to no ”undue influence of any sort. So far are we from ”being judges as well as legislators, that you ”decided yesterday that we are not judges; I mean, ”by your resolution, that this question should be ”determined by a simple majority of votes.”.........O De Chezeau Confinement and banishment..........................O G
71. LE CHER (BOURGES)
Foucher Death...............................................+ La Brunerie Death...............................................+
Page 212
Peltier Death...............................................+ Ala.s.seur ”What says history? Caesar was a.s.sa.s.sinated, and ”had a successor. The English sacrificed their ”tyrant, and returned to their chains. Rome ”banished her kings, and had liberty. I am for ”banishment.”.......................................O Baucheton Confinement.........................................O Dugene Confinement.........................................O
72. LA CORREZE (TULLES)
Brival Death...............................................+ Lannot Death, with discussion as to time...................D I Borie Death...............................................+ I Chambon Death...............................................+ G Lidon Death...............................................+ S Penieres Death...............................................+ Lafond ”I think it my duty to abstain from voting.” .......nv
Page 213
73. CORSE (_Corsica_) (BASTIA)
Salicetti Death...............................................+ Chiappe ”Having nothing to do with the application of ”punishment. I consider only the security of my ”fellow citizens, which is the supreme law; in a ”word, I am for detention.”.........................O Andree ”The punishment for Louis can be no other than that ”of forfeiture.”....................................O Bansio ”I flatter myself that I shall deserve well of my ”country in voting for detention.”..................O Peraldi Confinement and banishment..........................O Casabianca Provisional confinement.............................O Mottedo Confinement.........................................O
74. COTE D'OR (DIJON)
Bazire Death...............................................+ G Guyton- Death...............................................+ morveau
Page 214
Prieur Death...............................................+ P Oudot Death...............................................+ Treilhard Death...............................................+ Guyot Death, with discussion as to time...................D Berthier Death...............................................+ Lambert ”That I may not acc.u.mulate all functions, I think ”it is my duty to abstain from p.r.o.nouncing any ”juridical (sic) punishment.”.......................O Marcy ”The convention may set itself up for a jury; but ”it can be only to judge the crime, and not the ”criminal. To pa.s.s a definitive judgment upon ”Louis is, in my opinion, an outrage against the ”definitive will of the nation. To p.r.o.nounce ”sentence of death, is an usurpation of the right ”of the Sovereign. I will not be a judge--I ”cannot, and I ought not to be one.
” Representatives of the people! You have ”destroyed the despot; suffer the man to live. Let ”him drag in captivity a groveling life. You are ”the depositaries of French honour. Europe has her ”eyes upon you. Posterity is advancing. It will ”judge you, and its voice will pa.s.s through ages.” .O
Page 215
Rameau ”It is not in your power to give me the quality of ”judge, which I have not received from the ”sovereign. Accordingly I do not think myself ”bound by this monstrous decree.” ..................O
75. COTES DU NORD (ST. BRIEUX)
Londe Death...............................................+ Couppe ”Of the two punishments proposed to be inflicted on ”Louis, I choose the mildest, that is detention.”...O Champeaux ”My const.i.tuents have deputed me to make laws, and ”not to judge.”.....................................O
Page 216